Showing posts with label cars. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cars. Show all posts

Monday, 29 August 2011

TAKING MEANINGFUL ACTIONS


We are often asked what a person as an individual can do against the constant government and ‘’busy body’’ intrusion and bullying in their life.  We always come back with the same answer:  The best way to counter this ever increasing meddling in our private lives is to consistently fight for one’s beliefs and convictions, to express it loudly and clearly and to never surrender to bullying and disrespectful attitudes from both government and other citizens.  Joining and backing civil rights organizations has merit because the bigger the membership of groups such as ours the more of a menace our movement becomes, but unless one is willing to also fight this on a personal level, bringing balance and civility back to our society will be a lengthy painful process

When it comes to smoking, with the blessing and encouragement of our elected officials and unelected lobby groups, some fellow citizens are finding it perfectly acceptable to insult, denigrate, harass and bully people who smoke.  One such citizen and her employer has been shown a lesson in civility.  Indeed, Michelle Gervais from our sister organization Citizens for Civil Liberties in Ontario, had an unfortunate experience when checking in at the Bells Point Beach camping grounds in Sault Ste-Marie.  Contrary to some people, instead of becoming apologetic for being a smoker, she did exactly what everyone who is being harassed in similar ways should be doing.  The following self explanatory correspondence between Mrs. Gervais and the Bells Point Beach employee illustrates that meaningful actions such as the one Mrs. Gervais has taken can and will eventually bring back courteousness and respect.
 
To:  info@bellspointbeach.com
Bell's Point Camp Grounds
158 Highway 17 East
Garden River First Nation, Ontario
P6A 6Z3
Phone: 705-759-1561
Fax: 705-759-9084
Toll Free: 1-866-292-9902


Good day

I am the lady who had a reservation for 8 people last Thursday.  Upon our arrival, we were immediately greeted by a lady who threatened to call the police because we were smoking in our cars with our kids.

Ultimately I chose to leave the camp site rather than be harassed by a neurotic zealot during my vacation.

Please be advised that this incident, as well as your campsite location will be advertized on pro-choice websites across the world (Cage Canada, Citizen's for Civil Liberties, Freedom to Choose, Smoker's Club) in order to warn smoker's not to attempt to stay at your campsite.

Smoker's do not go on vacation in order to have other people tell them how to raise their children (I presume even non-smoker's don't go on vacation for that reason either).

I find it laughable that people at this park were so concerned about smoking in cars with kids but are willing to make a profit selling firewood that will be burned and envelop children in smoker.  Please feel free to google the chemical constituents of wood smoke and compare it with the smoke created by burning a handful of dried leaves.

I also find it laughable that you are so willing to "enforce" Ontario law in regards to smoking but still have your dog running loose without a leash or a muzzle and sell fireworks.

I wish you no harm but smoker's should know that you somehow feel qualified to tell them how to raise their children.  Even smoker's deserve to live free of harassment.  By advertising this incident, you will have the pleasure of operating a smoke-free campsite, as that is obviously your choice, and smoker's are free to choose to stay at a campsite where the operate behaves in a civilized manner and does not attempt to raise the children of their camper's.

Yours truly

Michelle Gervais, Director
Citizen's for Civil Liberties

From:  info@bellspointbeach.com 

Mrs. Gervais, you are absoultly right, I am deeply sorry for my behavior,
I have no right or excuse only regret, please be assured that I have
learned a valuble lesson on respect and how NOT to conduct my self from
both my employer and you, again I am very sorry. This is not how Bells
Point Beach conducts buisness.


Good day

Wednesday, 12 January 2011

SOUND SMOKING POLICY SHOULD BE BASED UPON SOUND SCIENCE NOT ON ''UNSTOPPABLE MOMENTUM''

Readers might remember that we brought to their attention back in April of 2010 an article that claimed that second hand smoke was twenty-three (23) times more toxic in cars, yet said claim was not based on any scientific evidence whatsoever. Of course, as we have highlighted frequently, the absence of solid scientific evidence has never stood in the way of public health policy when it comes to the smoking issue, but now the anti-tobacco crusaders are openly admitting to this.

Unable to quantify how dangerous second hand smoke is in a car , Rob Cunningham of the Canadian Cancer Society, now urges lawmakers to legislate based upon what he refers to as an “unstoppable momentum” and the perceived popularity of proposed anti-smoking measures instead of on the basis of scientific evidence. Little does it matter to this crusader that such a legislation is invasion of privacy and an undermining of parental authority. Forcing open the door even wider for the State to violate even more parental and privacy rights, these crusaders just want to get on with the program whether or not such legislation is actually justified.

Without even having to spend thousands or millions of dollars from the public purse on agenda-driven studies that torture the figures to come up with the desired results, we as a society should take a moment to think about and acknowledge that there are many other behaviours that parents engage in that are truly risky to their children when travelling by car. Driving in conditions of poor visibility, in snowstorms and on icy roads, in poorly maintained cars or with the distractions of eating and texting are some of the true risks parents regularly take when driving with their children.

Why are these do-gooders, professed protectors of other people’s children, obsessively focussing on second hand smoke for which they can not even properly appraise the risk instead of denouncing proven risky behaviours which are tangibly quantifiable? Why are some people supporting and applauding such agenda driven legislation that is based primarily on hype? These questions are not purely rhetorical. The answer is because anti-smoking has now become a profitable moral crusade where Mr. Cunningham’s so called “unstoppable momentum” is what drives policy and legislation.

This being said, most parents do not smoke with their small children in the car if for no other reason than to not to cause them discomfort. Those parents that do smoke usually crack a window open and allow the negative air pressure thus created to dissipate the smoke fairly quickly. Let parents be parents and let the Canadian Cancer Society use our donations to do research towards cures for real ailments instead of wasting them on agenda driven advocacy.

Sound smoking policy should be based upon sound science.

Tuesday, 7 October 2008

ABOUT SHODDY SCIENCE BY PRESS RELEASE

On our French comment of October 2nd we questioned the findings of a recent Canadian study that was published online ahead of print. It was a collaborative effort of researchers from McGill University, Université de Montréal, the University of British Columbia, Concordia University, the Institut national de santé publique du Québec (INSPQ) and the Direction de santé publique de Montréal, and several Canadian and international mainstream media reported the findings a few days ago.

The researchers were investigating whether never smoking children can get addicted by their parents’ second hand smoke. The study found that 5% of never smoking children may in fact get addicted to nicotine from their parents’ smoking. As we have learnt to expect when it comes to tobacco, the journalists reporting the study don't seem to have examined the methodology with a critical mind before reporting such loaded findings and if they did, they chose to ignore the flaws.

What caught our attention was that the media were reporting that the findings of the study were based on answers to a questionnaire given by a sample of 1488 10 – 12 year old never smoking children. We commented in our French article that in our opinion the methodology was quite unscientific since many biases could have crept in, including the unreliability of young children diagnosing their own symptoms and their personal dislike of the smell of cigarette smoke that may have influenced the way they replied. The conclusion being transparent as to its intent, specifically to support legislation forbidding smoking in motor vehicles with children, what we would have liked to examine as we stated, was if the questions asked could have possibly been leading to a predetermined conclusion.

Our ink was hardly dry on our own commentary, that Dr. Michael Siegel proceeded to carefully analyze the study. Our suspicions were thus confirmed.

Some excerpts of his commentary linked at the bottom:

‘’To my surprise, the study did not actually measure nicotine dependence among young neversmokers. Instead, what the study used was a nicotine dependence assessment tool that was designed specifically for smokers. The measurement tool that was used was not relevant to measuring nicotine dependence symptoms in nonsmokers. In fact, nearly all the questions assumed that the respondent was a smoker and these questions were therefore irrelevant and not applicable to these nonsmoking respondents. Any nonsmoking youth would have had considerable difficulty answering these questions which clearly did not apply to them.’’
(…)
‘’The conclusions of the study and the worldwide headlines are way overblown. In fact, overblown isn't really right because that suggests that the results are exaggerated. It is not a question of exaggeration. The conclusion is simply wrong. The results do not support - at all - the conclusion that these young children were nicotine dependent.’’
(…)
‘’One could design a set of questions to assess the possibility of nicotine dependence among young nonsmokers, but these questions would not be on the list to try. They are leading questions which are not relevant to nonsmokers and whose use will ensure that nicotine dependence is found among nonsmokers.’’
(…)
‘’In essence, this study was designed in such a way to create the very result it now reports. The study was set up such that it could not fail to find "nicotine dependence" among young nonsmokers. Furthermore, it was set up in such a way that it could not fail to find a correlation between "nicotine dependence" and secondhand smoke exposure.''

We have since written to the researchers of the study to inquire about what Dr. Siegel suggests are inexcusable flaws in their methodology and about their funding. How much did this shoddy piece of ''science'' cost Canadian taxpayers?

The most disturbing part is that even if a retraction is published in some remote section of the newspapers, the public who read the original headlines will remain with the misguided impression that ‘’smokers addict their children through their second hand smoke’’.

New Study Concludes that Secondhand Smoke Exposure May Cause Nicotine Dependence Among Young Neversmokers

Saturday, 15 December 2007

CMA ENCOURAGES A CANADA-WIDE BAN ON SMOKING IN CARS CARRYING CHILDREN

CMA Encourages a Canada-Wide Ban on Smoking in Cars Carrying Children is the title of the press release that you can read here.

As long time observers of the anti-smoking modus operandi, we suspected that the town of Wolfville, N.S. that banned smoking in cars with children, was implemented in order to set a precedent for the anti-smoking cartel that would open the door to a new phase of anti-smoking -- that of our cars, eventually and quickly to be followed by a ban in our homes.

Smoking in the presence of children is in no way, means or form to be considred parental neglect or abuse unless the child has a condition that second hand smoke can aggravate. Please read what Dr. Michael Siegel says on this subject
here. Risk does not automatically mean harm, especially when the risk factors are hardly at levels where cause can be inferred and all confounding factors can be dismissed. Epidemiology is too subjective, biased and inaccurate, for any legislation to be based on its weak and inconsistent conclusions. Case in point, the WHO’s biggest and most extensive study (Bofetta et al 1998) surprisingly found that second hand smoke protects children from lung cancer. Should we base legislation on this allegedly serious ‘’scientific’’ study and force all parents to smoke in the presence of children to save them from lung cancer?

Who then better than the parent, under the advice of the child’s pediatrician, knows best when a situation aggravates their child's condition and when it doesn’t? One could argue that some parents are negligent and could care less about their child’s medical condition and we agree that unfortunately such parents do exist -- thankfully in small numbers -- and by all means these children should be protected from this type of parental neglect. However, the fact is that there are laws already in place to protect children from parental neglect and abuse and it is those laws that should be enforced rigorously instead of wasting our already deficient human and financial resources to put ‘’feel good’’ laws in place that would not only be very difficult and expensive to enforce, but that would target all parents when in fact it is the few irresponsible ones that should be targeted.

Let’s not forget that if we’re going to legislate smoking behavior in order to save the children from their parents, we would have to review many risky habits that we allow our children to be subjected to, and legislate them in the same way, since they are all decisions parents make that pose a risk to their children. Such risky habits would include taking the child outside during smog alerts, driving in poor weather or in poor visibility conditions with a child, taking the child outdoors during mosquito season, caring for the child while we are afflicted with a viral or infectious disease, lighting candles, burning incense, lighting a fireplace in the presence of a child, the list is long and endless. The fact that we don't, is clear proof that these anti-smoking laws have absolutely nothing to do with children's health and everything to do with control, coercion and especially financial interests. Even the most caring parents take some type of risk while a child is in their custody and under their authority and that is perfectly acceptable. Why should it be any different when it comes to smokers to the point that special legislation is required?

If the citizens of this country keep bending to these manipulative campaigns that use children to appeal to our emotions, there really is no telling, depending on the activist agenda ‘’du jour’’, when government bureaucrats will be knocking on our door to inspect what we’re serving our children for breakfast and if the TV set is on a channel appropriate for their age.

Smoking bans in cars with children are peddled by the pharmaceutically financed anti-smoking cartel for the sole purpose of de-normalizing smokers and further turning them into social pariahs who should be ruthlessly shamed into quitting, hopefully with the help of their pharmaceutical products. It is time citizens of all provinces and countries begin to see clearly through these immoral and unethical tactics brought on by anti-smoking organizations eager to satisfy their corporate donors -- Big Pharma.